2025-04-07

Excuse me, does this journal only accept field experiments?

2025-04-02

I have never had such a terrible submission experience. The editor is Xin Chen from Zhejiang University. After the first submission, it was rejected due to issues with the method description. There were only a few comments provided, two of which were already described in the paper but the editor did not see them. It is obvious that the editor is rejecting the submission just for the sake of rejection. After seeking permission to make modifications and resubmit, it was rejected again with the reason being that it was a previously rejected submission. WTH??? Everyone should be cautious when submitting their work.

2025-03-25

Bro, how long has it been since you made your first decision? It's been 20 days for me and I'm feeling a bit numb.

2025-02-28

The major revision went back to a reviewer, and then a new one was found by the editor. However, the new reviewer accepted it directly, and it went quite smoothly.

2025-02-23

Could you please go back to make revisions and invite new reviewers for editing?

2025-02-11

2024.10.19 submitted
2024.12.9 overhauled
2024.12.19 return
2025.1.24 accept

2025-01-16

2024.07.30 submit
2024.08.01 with editor (changed twice, then sent for review)
2024.08.04 under review (invited two reviewers)
2024.10.31 major revision
2024.11.20 revise
2024.11.20 under review on the same day (only one reviewer agreed to review, one ran away)
2025.01.16 accept
The total time was five and a half months. The editor of AGEE was particularly responsible, handling the manuscript every eight days without any long delays in the review process.

2025-01-04

Currently, the status of the two papers are as follows:
First paper: Submitted on 7.25, under review on 29.
Major revision on 8.26 (four reviewers), resubmitted for revision in 21 days on 9.16.
Reviewers disappeared, re-invited on 9.16.
Major revision on 12.3, resubmitted for revision in 14 days on 12.17.
Returned on 12.15, under review on 12.19 (2 reviewers).

Second paper: Submitted on 10.11, under review on 10.22.
Major revision on 12.3 (two reviewers), resubmitted for revision in 21 days on 12.29.
Under review on 2025.1.2.

2024-12-26

The submission was made on December 10th and is currently with the editor. On the 12th, the date was changed once but the status remains with the editor. It has now been 16 days.

2024-12-11

The first round of revisions will be completed by the end of June or July, giving about a month. Two new reviewers will then conduct the second round of revisions, which took until November to complete. The revisions were minor and took two weeks. The revised manuscript was submitted a few days ago and is currently with the editor. We are waiting for further instructions.